ACM warns attorneys of invisible record materials

By Steve Klepper

The Appellate Court yesterday reported an opinion warning attorneys that the appellate record may contain items invisible to them. Judge Joseph Getty, writing for the Court in Curry v. State, rejected a criminal defendant’s challenge that the circuit court clerk failed to enter the relevant jury notes into the record.

The clerk jury notes were in the record, even though counsel could not see them because of MDEC security settings:

We take this opportunity to note that counsel should be aware of the different security settings in the Maryland Electronic Courts (“MDEC”) system and how those settings impact access to record documents. MDEC is the electronic case management processing and record-keeping system used in the State of Maryland’s court system.

“Through MDEC, state courts ‘collect, store and process records electronically, and will be able to access complete records instantly as cases travel from District Court to Circuit Court[.]’ In essence, MDEC allows for paper records to be available online and on demand.” Att’y Grievance Comm’n of Md. v. Weinberg, 485 Md. 504, 540 n.22 (2023). When a circuit court clerk assigns a document an enhanced security designation in MDEC that restricts access to judges and court personnel (“Judge/Court Personnel Only”), the document remains part of the record, but is not visible to counsel as a docket entry, nor is it included in the Appeal Index.

This aspect of MDEC’s security system poses particular difficulty for appellate counsel who did not participate in the proceedings below. Although in this case, during the hearing on Mr. Curry’s motion to dismiss, the motions judge explained that the jury notes were “locked” in MDEC because they were confidential documents not for public viewing, the documents in question were restricted to judges and court personnel only. As a result, counsel for this case could not see that any such documents existed in the record.

Counsel should not assume that the absence of a document from the Appeal Index means that it was not filed or is not part of the record. Instead, counsel should promptly notify the appropriate court personnel, often the circuit court clerk, and request access to the relevant documents. When appropriate, the circuit court may modify the document’s security designation to the less restrictive “Confidential,” thereby permitting counsel to review it while continuing to restrict public access.

This holding was the only point listed on the Headnotes on the opinion’s cover page, suggesting that this issue drove the full Court’s vote to report the opinion.

Curry raises broader questions about how MDEC is administered across the 24 circuit courts, why the appellate index does not identify “locked” materials, and what appellate counsel’s obligations are to figure out what invisible materials might exist but were “locked” in error. In the interest of posting Curry‘s important guidance ASAP, I will simply note for now that in federal court, the CM/ECF public docket lists any such restricted item as a “SEALED DOCUMENT,” so that when I am appointed as Criminal Justice Act appellate counsel I know what questions to ask the district court clerk when fulfilling my obligation to review the entire record.

Leave a Reply